Monday, January 30, 2012

Entry 9-Abstract

Here is my unadulterated abstract, which I wrote up in about 20 minutes yesterday. I would love some feedback on what people think about the breadth of the topic and if you have any suggestions for sources (or how else to narrow down the topic) that would be fantastic! Enjoy:

Egyptology, the formal study of Ancient Egypt, began with the invasion of Napoleon in to Egypt. With him he brought “Savants” who began to study ancient Egyptian ruins and attempt to explore Egypt’s past before Islam. These events lead to a revitalized interest in Egypt as the birthplace of civilization and started a European rivalry that would extend into the 20th century. However, it was not until the rise of the Nationalist movement in the early 20th century that Egyptians became involved in the study of their own Ancient Past. Although images of the Great Pyramids and the Sphinx were on heavily circulated items such as paper money and postage stamps, few Egyptians were involved in the study of the Ancient past. The few who did attempt to make this study were blocked from teaching others because of funding or their European counterparts. Notably these included Ahmed Kamal, Marcus Saimka, and Ali Mubarak who were all the first in their fields to represent Egyptians in the field of Archaeology. While many Egyptians were not clear on the details of their past, Nationalists were quick to use those symbols to encourage separation from the British. These Pharaonic themes can be seen in Egyptian art of the Nationalist period and still permeate arts in Egypt today. However, this appropriation of symbols carries with it another underlying theme that few have explored. The connection between images of women and this Egyptological discourse. Many statues that contain Pharaonic themes, such as Nahdet Misr, portray the ancient world as a female or in juxtaposition with the image of a modern Egyptian woman.

For this research project, I will examine 3 architectural portrays of females in pharaonic styles from the early 20th century. I would like to answer two important questions. First, why was it that public portrayal of Ancient Egyptians chose to portray females rather than males? Was it because of the relationship between Egyptian connotation of “Pharaohs” or a by-product of individual design choices? Second, how does the feminist discourse of the early 20th century explore the portrayal of Ancient women? How far did feminist discourse draw in the past to explain the position of women in Egyptian society? Or is this time period ignored in favor of more well-known Islamic examples? Has this discourse changed at all with Egypt’s true independence and now the Arab Spring?

To answer these questions, I will look at both primary and secondary source material. For Primary source material I am looking specifically the Nahdet Misr statue, Sa’ad Zaghlul’s Mausoleum, the façade of the Egyptian Museum, the statue of Mustafa Kamil, the memoirs of Huda Shaarawi, and 2 famous women biographies that describe the lives of Queen Nefertari and that of Pharaoh Nitocris. As for secondary source material I will explore what work has already been done to relate these pieces of evidence to the general values of the Nationalist and the Feminist movement in the early 20th century. I would also like to read accompanying histories to the monuments themselves in order to explore the choice of the builders to included pharaonic themes in their art.

My preliminary research suggests that the portrayal of females on the façade of the Egyptian Museum represented the rise of Neopharaonic styles in European architecture rather than any nationalist want to revitalize an old style. The museum was built by Europeans and for Europeans since many of the inscriptions on the outside are written in latin and not a single Egyptian who participated in Egyptology is inscribed on the outside. The presence of women on other statues suggests the incorporation of the Nationalists perception of the whole nation as a household and as Egypt as a “Mother” country. This is supported by the famous women biographies that portray Queen Nefertari and Pharaoh Nitocris as good housewives that still maintained a public face and were able to rule Ancient Egypt themselves.

Entry 9A-Preliminary Bibliography

This was the preliminary bibliography I turned in with my abstract.

Hassan, Fekri A.. “Memorabilia: Archaeological materiality and national identity in Egypt” in Archaeology Under Fire: Nationalism, politics, and heritage in the Eastern Mediterranean and Middle East, edited by Lynn Meskell. 200-217. New York: Routledge, 1998.

Reid, Donald. Whose Pharaohs?. Los Angeles: University of California Press, 2002.

Marsot , Afaf Lutfi Al-Sayyid, “The Revolutionary Gentlewomen in Egypt” in Women in the Muslim World, edited by Lois Beck and Nikki R. Keddie. 261-277. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1978.

Philipp, Thomas “Feminism and Nationalist Politics in Egypt” in Women in the Muslim World, edited by Lois Beck and Nikki R. Keddie.277-295. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1978.

Booth, Marilyn. “ ‘May Her Likes Be Multiplied’: ‘Famous Women’ Biography and Gendered Prescription in Egypt, 1892-1935” Signs 22(1997): 827-890.

Petrie, W.M. Flinders. Social life in Ancient Egypt. London: Constable & Company LTD, 1923.

El-Aref, Nevine. “A puzzle comes to a head.” Al-Ahram Weekly Online, 2-8 August 2001.< http://weekly.ahram.org.eg/2001/545/eg5.htm>

-“Back in the Limelight.” Al-Ahram Weekly Online, 28 June – 4 July 2007..

- “From legend to drama queen.” Al-Ahram Weekly Online, 23-29 September 2010. .

- “Nefertiti Always and forever.” Al-Ahram Weekly Online, 26 June – 2 July 2003 .

- “Queen for a day.” Al-Ahram Weekly Online, 14 June – 20 June 2007 .

- “Heritage at what cost?.”Al-Ahram Weekly Online, 12-18 January 2012 .

Emama, Amr “Feminist Saadawi doesn’t fear death.” The Egyptian Gazette Online, 7 January 2010 [Accessed date. http://213.158.162.45/~egyptian/index.php?action=news&id= 1161&title=Feminist%20Saadawi%20doesn%E2%80%99t%20fear%20death.]

El-Saadawi, Nawal “Writers in the Revolution: Nawal El-Saadawi’s greatest pleasure in meeting all sorts of Egyptians.” Ahramonline, 16 Feb 2011 [Accessed Date. http://english.ahram.org.eg/News/5640.aspx.]

-“Woman at the Time of the Pharaohs” in Hidden Face of Eve. Nawal El-Saadawi. 108-115. London: Zed Press, 1980.

Sunday, January 29, 2012

Entry 8-Halim El-Dabh

I finally feel like I am getting a firm grip on some primary sources that are not statues. I read an article by Halim El-Dabh who is a well known ethnomusicologist about his experience with the arts in Egypt "Today" (1981). He mentions many times the presence of Pharaonic themes in weaving, monastic practices, and in music as well. He doesn't go into much detail but it is clear that the presence of Ancient Egypt makes a big impression on what he believes makes up modern Egyptian identity. However, like many other sources the exact details of those "Pharaonic themes" remains as mysterious as that past.

Thursday, January 26, 2012

Entry 7--Famous Women Biographies

So after having a good chat with Lopez and rereading some of my articles for class I think I finally have some womens' sources that explore Egyptology, or at least a starting point. For next week we read an article called "May her likes be Multiplied" which has now been turned into a book by the same name. The article talks about these biographies of famous women that were incorporated into many women's journals during the early feminist movement. (Un?)Surprisingly, a few of the famous women that were written about were in fact ancient queens of Egypt. Particularly Pharaoh Nitocris and Nefertari, which are sort of cliched. However, it is at least an example of women during the early feminist movement, or at least literate elite women, engaging with the expanding presence of Egyptology. I requested the article about Nefertari from interlibrary loan. Although, I won't be able to read the piece there might be a picture or something that I could use and I can maybe find someone to translate it for me and then use it as a source. Other than that, I've got some insight now into the formulation of the family or "domesticity" into the public sphere (ie if the country was like a home or the country like a mother then domestic life was also public life) which may be useful in interpreting the use of female but ancient images on lots of monuments celebrating the Nationalist movement...we'll see what happens.

Tuesday, January 24, 2012

Entry 6-Notes from a Meeting

Ah so many in one day! Actually its because I had my meeting with my Professor and finally have some more guidance. So instead of going from source material and then a question I'm going from question outwards (how novel). Anyways I think my guiding question will be something like

How has the knowledge or study of Ancient Egypt or Egyptology affected or intersected with Egyptian Feminist Discourse if at all?

I think that is what I am going for and now I need to read some memoirs and writings of Egyptian feminists, male and female, to see if this occurs. Huzzah! Anyways I also wanted to put up my general and random notes about what I have found so far, please stop me of I'm boring you.

Lopez suggested that I possibly talk to Joel Walker about this topic since he researches in this general area as well. I have met him once or twice before, in very informal ways, so it might be an interesting chance to talk with him about an actual research topic. Besides that he also suggested that I look at the Mustafa Kamil Statue which is very famous and has stuff written about it. Specifically a monograph by Israel Gershoni and James Jankowski. He also suggested that I explore current Egyptian feminist rhetoric to see if any of it extends past the great movement of 1919 for inspiration. He also suggested that I look into works by Salamah Musa who's a big philosopher and might have made connections between feminist rhetoric and pharaonic motifs. There's his biography called The education of Salāma Mūsā:= Tarbiyat Salāmah Mūsa that I might look into. There was also Badran's book Feminists, Islam, and Nation and the book May Her Likes Be Multiplied which talks about the mini biographies written by Egyptian women about other notable women. I might also want to explore when and where the invocation of early Islamic perception of women played into Egyptian feminism. He also suggested that I look at the wife of Sa'd Zaghloul who was a major player in Egyptian Feminism. Other than that he also gave me the e-mail address for an anthropology graduate student who worked on this sort of thing. Ta ta for now!

Entry 5--Art, Archives, and Architecture

I reread some of the articles this week for my class and have gotten some sources that might be helpful in my search for information on my topic. I am going to pick up a memoir called Harem Years: The memoirs of an Egyptian Feminist and an article called "The Revolutionary Gentlewomen of Egypt". These are closer to general readings for my class but I think that they will explore if there was any discourse by Egyptian women that dealt with the issue of Ancient women's identity. Also the memoirs span the time when all of the monuments that I am going to discuss were built so any mention of them and their architecture would be very useful. I also just did a google scholar search and found a paper presented by Dr. Hisham Hussein Azmi from Cairo University (http://www.sea1917.org/heritage/UIA-WPAHR-V/Papers-PDF/Dr.%20Hesham%20Azmy.pdf)that discusses Egypt's Architectural identity and explores Nahdet Misr. There are quite a few free online PDFs like this but those related to scholarly publications are a bit harder to find. Google Scholar(also found this article (http://www.academy.ac.il/data/egeret/70/EgeretArticles/somekh%20article%203.pdf) but its on Naguib Mahfouz and I'm not sure exactly what it has to do with the Saad Zaghloul statue but I will continue looking!

Entry 4-in a State of Statues

So it has been a while since I posted on this and we've had snow but I know thats snow excuse (puns!). Anyways I think I might have a meeting with my professor today about my topic. I have decided to focus on three architectural features or statues that are modern but incorporate ancient themes. I've decided to focus on Nahdet Misr or Egypt's Renaissance statue, the pedestal embellishments on Saad Zaghloul's statue in Alexandria, and some of the adornments of the Egyptian Museum (antiquities). All three have some sort of Ancient Egyptian theme but also relate to a modern peception of the sculptor or architect and explore the changing perceptions of Ancient Egypt.

The Egyptian Museum is the oldest and is an example of what western minds thought about Ancient Egypt. It was built in the early 1900s. Then comes Nahdet Misr around 1915 which has a sphynx, but with a more masculine face, and a fully robed woman. And lastly there is the statue of Saad Zaghloul which was erected in 1935. It has the image of a man (Saad Zaghloul?) but on the base there are 2 smaller sculptures of Ancient Egyptian-looking women. These were created in very turbulent times when the perception of Egypt's identity was hotly debated. I also find it extremely interesting that the three monuments all incorporate an image of woman in some way.

I have the book by Reid that explores the Museum and its symbolism but I need to find out more about Nahdet Misr and the statue of Saad Zaghloul. I found an article on Al-Ahram Weekly (http://weekly.ahram.org.eg/2006/789/chrncls.htm) that talks about the "war of statues in Alexandria" and I think it is a good source to look at a (possible) Egyptian perception of these monuments. I also have a book chapter by Fekri A. Hassan who I believe is an archaeologist. His chapter is in Archaeology Under Fire: Nationalism, politics, and heritage in the Eastern Mediterranean and Middle East and is entitled "Memorabilia: Archaeological materiality and national identity in Egypt". I briefly discussed this article earlier but I think in light of my selection I should look at it again. Other than that I am still looking for sources and will poke around Hassan's article for more and look for more articles on Al-Ahram Weekly's page but it sometimes has trouble searching.

Thursday, January 12, 2012

Entry 3-and then there were Pharaohs

I know! why wasn't this just in entry 2 (not that anyone knows this exists :P) but I just looked up some famous female pharaohs on a site of dubious knowledge. A few sound promising but I'm not sure how I should proceed with this.

http://www.ancientnile.co.uk/pharaohs-women.php

^^That's the URL and it has a list of different female Pharaohs. I feel like I'd probably pick the one that talks about the woman who is depicted as wearing man's dress and hopefully find some articles about the discovery/interpretation of those images and get all gender historical on that. Though, stemming from my hesitancy to approach this topic at all, I don't want to fall into a sort of pseudo report. I have always felt that Egyptology, no offense to those who do it in a scholarly manner, are what people who have no idea about archaeology want to do. I feel like the interest in it rests in a fascination with the exoticness of the ancient world. So that's why I hesitate about this a bit. What I'd like to do is read a bit more, a little from Archaeologies of Social theory , Archaeology and Women: Ancient & Modern issues , Whose Pharaohs?, and my crash course Egyptology book before I look for stuff more specific. I think then that I will be in a good place to look for concrete things and perhaps start saying something.

Entry 2-Thoughts on Theory

So after reading some more very hard to read social theory, good but I'm still not quite sure what I can or cannot say, I have come to this conclusion about my project so far: I need to focus on a single site or particular ancient woman or momument that incorporates ancient themes if I want to stick to an archaeological related topic. If I try anything else it will be very hard to search as well as collate all the information. Using an Egyptian queen might be a good idea or looking at Egyptian women in the field of archaeology may be a good idea.

I got another book on the topic that might introduce some more possible topics for me. This book is called Archaeology and Women: Ancient & Modern Issues and has chapters on many different places and many different examples of the intersection between women and the topic. I would also like to e-mail Lynn Meskell after I've read a bit more of her book and ask her about how it was, maybe, to work with the material and maybe about female egyptian Archaeologists.

Other than that my idea has been, if I pick a particular ancient woman or monument, is to relate initial interpretation of them by British archaeologists and compare those interpretations with modern understandings and perhaps even with popular beliefs about these things. I would like to relate them to common or "lay" person understandings or see how, if ever, they are framed within a more "Muslim" context.

Tuesday, January 10, 2012

Entry one-What's this?

I thought this would be a good way to start writing and think a bit more about my research project in my history class.

My basic want is to explore the intersection of archaeological interpretations of the Egyptian past and their modern understandings of gender. Either looking through time at the incorporation of females in archaeological sites, such as is addressrf in the book Archaeologies of Social Life by Lynn Meskell, females as archaeologists and more importantly the awareness of the Egyptian people of the position of ancient women. This has of course quite a few components and is rather broad topic and I would like to focus more specifically on a single site or monument but in order to do that I will need to do some crash course like reading on the topic in general.

My professor pointed me towards some readings that I plan on starting soon, such as Whose Pharaohs? , which deals with Egyptian archaeology and nationalism. A chapter in Lynn Meskell's Archaeology Under Fire specifically addressed the relationship between different political movements in Egypt and their archaeological past but it was not particularly detailed. It mentioned that politicals would "remind" themselves, and the Egyptian people, of the great ancient past but didn't mention any specific sites or people that they where inspired by. This either suggests that perhaps it was just the idea of a "great" ancient civilization that they used or that the author was generalizing. I think that Whose Pharaohs? will be able to provide that detail.

On the Archaeological side, I began reading Lynn Meskell's Archaeologies of Social Life to get more archaeological information about a specific site. Her focus is on a specific site Deir el Medina also known as "The village" that has more archaeological evidence that can be corroborated with some textual information. I also named this blog URL after it in a way (Deir el Feminina) However, before she analyzes this site she explores some of the theoretical paradigms that have impacted archaeology but have, to a certain extent, passed over Egyptology. Particularly the role of women (or gender) and the social sciences currently as well the different stages of philosophy.